MLB Umpiring in Playoffs

Perfect Game Call

UMPIRE WAS RIGHT .GALARRAGA DID NOT HAVE COMPLETE POSSESION OF BALL.HIS FINAL SWIPING OF GLOVE IN AIR WAS DONE AFTER BATTER TOUCHED FIRST. SAFE.CORRECT CALL.LOOK AT REPLAY CAREFULLY. YOU WILL SEE WHAT I MEAN.

THE PERFECT GAME

Last year's fiasco wasn't one actually.If one looks at the play closely,the ump made the right call: the ball was not under complete control when first caught and control was there,the runner had reached first.Jim should not have admitted to any mistake but he did not make one.The runner was safe.

Umpiring or rule questions welcome.

Where are all the umpires? Your questions please.

umpiring

what is the high in umpiring baseball? is it the control,the challenge.It must be all of that and more.your suggestions,comments or reactions to this are appreciated. bye for now